Meaning of "Popular" by Nada Surf

"Popular" can be interpreted as a critique of societal expectations and the pressure to conform to standards of popularity. The dialogues between the girls highlight their concerns about being in steady relationships and the pressure to be attractive. The advice on breaking up focuses on honesty and directness, suggesting that honesty is the best policy even if it may lead to hurt feelings. The lyrics then shift to the protagonist's obsession with popularity, listing various attributes and accomplishments that contribute to their popularity. However, the song takes a satirical turn when it suggests implementing a one month limit on going steady, implying that relationships should be short-lived and easily replaceable. This suggestion highlights the shallow and superficial nature of popularity.

The repeated chorus of being a "head of the class" and a "quarterback" represents the idealized image of popularity in high school. It emphasizes the superficiality that often accompanies popularity and the pressures to conform to societal standards. The song also alludes to the idea that popularity is fleeting and can result in a sense of isolation, as the protagonist mentions making football bets and being a teacher's pet, further highlighting the lack of genuine connection and the performance required to maintain popularity.

The final verse proposes a "Teenage Guide to Popularity," which seems comical and unrealistic. It suggests that conforming to societal expectations and seeking popularity is not a sustainable or fulfilling way to live. The song ultimately encourages listeners to question the importance of popularity and instead focus on being true to themselves and forming genuine connections.