Meaning of "Carnival" by Natalie Merchant

"Carnival" explores the idea of self-reflection and questioning one's perception of reality. The opening lines suggest a sense of detachment, as the streets are described as a "virtual stage" and the people as "actors." The protagonist is surrounded by the hustle and bustle of the carnival, witnessing the "cheap thrill seekers" and the "vendors and the dealers." This imagery highlights the superficiality and temporary nature of the carnival, emphasizing the idea that people are caught up in seeking momentary satisfaction.

The protagonist then contemplates their own state of mind, wondering if they have been blind or lost within their own thoughts. They question whether they have been hypnotized and mesmerized by what their eyes have seen. This suggests that the protagonist is grappling with the notion that their perception of reality may have been influenced or distorted. The mention of the "diamond market" and the "scarlet welcome carpet" symbolizes the stark contrast between wealth and poverty. The carnival becomes a metaphorical representation of society, where material wealth is celebrated while those who are marginalized are treated as outcasts.

The lyrics then introduce a "wild-eyed misfit prophet" who raves about saving the protagonist. This encounter can be seen as a moment of revelation or awakening. The protagonist questions whether they have been wrong or wise to shut their eyes and play along with the illusions. The repetition of the line "by what my eyes have found" further emphasizes the theme of perception and the transformative power of self-reflection.

In the final lines, the protagonist reflects on their experiences in the "great street carnival." This can be interpreted as a recognition of the duality of life itself, where joy and sorrow, pleasure and pain coexist. The carnival serves as a metaphor for the chaotic and ever-changing nature of existence.

Overall, "Carnival" delves into the human experience and the complexities of self-awareness. It prompts listeners to question their own perceptions and the societal constructs that may shape their understanding of reality.