The lyrics tell the story of a soldier who is approached by a girl asking him to marry her before he goes off to fight. Each time she asks, the soldier claims he cannot marry her because he lacks the appropriate clothing item, until eventually he reveals he already has a wife at home.

Meaning of "Soldier, Soldier" by Natalie Merchant

The song "Soldier, Soldier" by Natalie Merchant seems to be a cautionary tale about false promises and deceit. The girl in the story represents innocence and naivety, while the soldier symbolizes deception and disloyalty. The repeated pattern of the soldier's excuses highlights how he manipulates the girl's feelings to avoid commitment. The final revelation that he has a wife at home adds a layer of betrayal and deceit, showcasing the soldier's true nature. The lyrics could be seen as a metaphor for how people use excuses to avoid taking responsibility for their actions, especially in relationships. It serves as a reminder to be cautious of those who make empty promises and to look beyond appearances to uncover the truth.