Meaning of "The Gulf Of Araby" by Natalie Merchant

The song appears to be a reflection on the longing for things that are out of reach, whether it be personal desires or the resolution of conflicts. The references to "fill a veil with shells from Killiney's shore" and "bridge The Gulf of Araby" suggest a yearning for connection and unity that seems impossible to achieve. The mention of various atrocities and injustices, such as "neighbors who are proud of their massacres" and "prisoners framed by a dirty judge," adds a layer of social commentary on the state of the world. The repeated refrain "what is, what is, what is, and what can never be" underscores the theme of acceptance and resignation to the fact that some things may never change or come to pass. Overall, the lyrics paint a poignant picture of longing, loss, and the struggle for hope in the face of adversity.