Meaning of "Hearts and Bones" by Paul Simon

In "Hearts and Bones," Paul Simon delves into the intricacies of a love affair and its impact on two individuals. The wandering Jews in the lyrics represent the protagonists, who are free to wander as they choose but ultimately find themselves on a journey together in the Sangre de Cristo Mountains of New Mexico. This physical journey serves as a metaphor for their emotional journey, which began a long time ago.

The "arc of a love affair" symbolizes the ups and downs of their relationship, with memories of the past and cracks in their connection coming to the forefront. The marriage they shared was unconventional, with the bride being described as contagious and burning like a bride. This may suggest that their relationship was passionate and intense, but also potentially destructive.

The man in the song reflects on the events leading up to their current state and how it may have affected him. The love affair is portrayed as tumultuous, with lightning-like love that shakes until it moans. It becomes apparent that the woman desires a deeper level of love and asks why the man won't love her for who she is and where she is. His response indicates that he loves her in his own way, implying that the world does not always conform to the ideals of love and relationships.

In the latter half of the song, the wandering Jews return to their natural coasts and resume old acquaintances. There is a sense of longing for the past and a hope that their love affair can be restored. The idea of two bodies being twirled into one symbolizes the merging of hearts and bones, an intimate connection that is difficult to undo.

Overall, "Hearts and Bones" explores the complexities of love, marriage, and the challenges faced within relationships. It portrays a journey of emotional ups and downs, reflecting on the past and contemplating the potential for reconciliation.