Meaning of "Tenderness" by Paul Simon

In this song, Paul Simon explores the concept of honesty and its relationship with tenderness in a romantic relationship. The repetition of the question "What can I do" emphasizes the speaker's sense of helplessness and frustration in trying to navigate the dynamics of the relationship. While the other person is praised for their honesty, the speaker highlights the absence of tenderness beneath this honesty. The juxtaposition of "right and wrong" with the inability to "get along" suggests that straightforward honesty may not always lead to a harmonious connection. The line "You and me were such good friends" indicates that there was once a strong bond between the two individuals, but something has changed. The speaker expresses a willingness to reconcile and make amends, but also recognizes that this may not be reciprocated, as emphasized by the repetition of "I'm not worried."

The chorus, with its plea for tenderness, highlights the speaker's longing for a deeper emotional connection. The phrase "Oh, honesty, it's such a waste of energy" suggests that plain honesty alone is not enough to sustain a meaningful relationship, reinforcing the theme of the song. The narrator desires tenderness, which represents affection, care, and understanding, to accompany honesty. The final line "Just give me some tenderness beneath your honesty" encapsulates the central message of the song: that honesty without tenderness is incomplete and unsatisfying. It suggests that a relationship requires emotional vulnerability and sensitivity in addition to truthfulness.

Overall, "Tenderness" explores the complexities of human relationships, highlighting the importance of openness and emotional connection. It suggests that honesty alone is not enough to sustain a healthy and fulfilling partnership, emphasizing the need for tenderness to accompany truthfulness.