Meaning of "If I Were a Carpenter" by Ramblin' Jack Elliott

The lyrics of "If I Were a Carpenter" delve into the theme of love and whether it can withstand societal expectations and roles. The speaker uses the professions of carpenter, tinker, and miller to symbolize unconventional or lower-status occupations. By questioning whether their partner would still love them if they pursued these paths, the speaker is examining the depth and authenticity of their relationship.

The repetition of the question, "Would you marry me anyway, could you have my baby," speaks to the speaker's need for reassurance and commitment. They want to know if their partner's love is strong enough to withstand any potential societal judgment or criticism that may arise from deviating from traditional gender roles or expectations.

The refrain, "Save my love for sorrow, save my love for lonely, I've given you my tomorrow, love me only," reflects the speaker's emotional vulnerability and longing for a love that transcends societal norms. They are willing to give their all, but they desire reciprocation and assurance that their love will be cherished and prioritized.

The final stanza further explores the idea of societal expectations and their potential impact on love. The question about missing the colored blouse and soft shoes shining implies that the speaker may have previously held a higher social status or indulged in material possessions. By asking if their partner would miss these things, they are testing whether love can transcend materialism and appearances.

Overall, "If I Were a Carpenter" portrays a search for unconditional love and acceptance. The speaker challenges societal norms and role expectations, wanting to know if their partner's love is strong enough to navigate through any obstacles. This song serves as a reflection on the transformative power of love and the desire for a genuine connection that transcends societal constructs.