Meaning of "Why Must I Plead" by Richard Thompson

The lyrics of "Why Must I Plead" by Richard Thompson delve into the themes of betrayal, heartbreak, and disillusionment in a romantic relationship. The narrator expresses feelings of hurt and confusion as they witness their partner's actions that suggest infidelity and lack of commitment. The references to bitterness, lies, and jealousy paint a picture of a once happy and passionate relationship soured by deceit and indifference. The mention of friends being indiscreet and the partner being evasive and dismissive further highlight the breakdown in communication and trust. The repeated question of "Why must I plead with you darling, for what's already mine" reflects the narrator's struggle to come to terms with the changing dynamics of the relationship and the realization that their partner may not value them as they once did. Overall, the lyrics capture the pain of unreciprocated love and the sense of powerlessness that comes with trying to salvage a doomed connection.