The narrator sees their loved one upon docking the ship, feeling a rush of emotions and memories. Despite acknowledging their family and responsibilities, they struggle with a decision to forgive or forget the person in front of them.

Meaning of "I'm Not Ready To Forgive You" by Right Away, Great Captain!

The lyrics depict a complex mix of emotions that arise when faced with someone from the past who has caused pain or heartache. The narrator's initial reaction of falling back in love upon seeing the person again highlights the complexity of human relationships and the struggle to let go of past feelings. The mention of the family waiting in the background signifies the internal conflict between personal desires and responsibilities. The reference to being a "murderer" presents the idea of having to choose whether to let go of the past or hold onto it, potentially destroying something in the process. The repeated refrain of "I'm not ready to forgive you, I'm not ready to forget you" encapsulates the internal turmoil and indecision the narrator faces in dealing with the past.