Meaning of "Heaven Knows" by Robert Plant

The lyrics of "Heaven Knows" delve into the internal struggle of the narrator as they reflect on their own actions and the decisions they made. The opening lines describe a new individual who seems attractive, confident, and attention-seeking. This person is described as being "razor sharp" and "firm and tan," suggesting physical and aesthetic attractiveness. However, they are also portrayed as shallow and lacking depth, with a "thirty-second attention span." This character represents a contrasting image to the narrator's own perspective.

The narrator then questions themselves, asking "What kind of fool am I?" and expressing confusion about taking an "eye for an eye." This indicates a moment of self-reflection, where the narrator realizes that they may have made foolish decisions or engaged in vengeful behavior. The imagery of "pumping iron" versus "pumping irony" represents a dichotomy between physical fitness and the narrator's own detached and ironic mindset. It suggests that while others may be focused on physical strength and self-improvement, the narrator is instead focused on employing irony as a defense mechanism or coping mechanism.

The song also touches on themes of family pride and secrecy. The line "With your head, heart, arms and legs wrapped around my family pride" suggests that the narrator's actions or decisions may have been influenced by a desire to protect their family's image or reputation. However, this involvement seems to have left the narrator feeling only "half alive," indicating a sense of emptiness or lack within their own life.

The lyrics also mention the "Tonton Macoute," a reference to the paramilitary force in Haiti known for their brutality and violence. This reference adds a layer of darkness and cynicism, suggesting that there is an element of danger or wrongdoing in the narrator's actions or mindset. It highlights the contrast between romance and violence, suggesting that the narrator's experiences or relationships may be distorted or tainted.

Overall, "Heaven Knows" explores questions of self-reflection, regret, and the complexities of human nature. The narrator grapples with their own choices and their contrasting perspective to others, ultimately questioning their own identity and seeking understanding.