Meaning of "Broken Bones" by Roger Waters

In "Broken Bones," Roger Waters contemplates the insignificance of human existence when confronted with the vastness of the universe. Staring at the night sky and seeing stars billions of light years away, he realizes how small and inconsequential his own life feels. This existential contemplation leads him to question the value of individual existence. The repetition of "Who gives a shit anyway?" emphasizes a sense of futility and apathy, suggesting that ultimately, the cosmic scale of the universe diminishes the importance of human life.

Waters then reflects on the aftermath of World War II and the missed opportunity to rebuild society in a more just and compassionate way. Instead of learning from the devastation and brokenness of the war, humanity chose to prioritize wealth accumulation and the pursuit of the American Dream. The reference to "broken bones" symbolizes the physical and emotional scars left by the war, which could have served as a reminder of the need for change. However, society opted for abundance and materialism, ignoring the opportunity for genuine freedom and transformation.

The song also speaks to the abandonment of liberty, symbolized by Mistress Liberty, most likely referring to the Statue of Liberty. Waters laments how society has forsaken the values of freedom and democracy. The repetition of "How we abandoned thee" suggests regret and guilt for turning away from the ideals that the statue represents.

Furthermore, Waters explores the cycle of violence and indoctrination. He muses that children are born innocent and unaware of the conflicts and prejudices that divide humanity. However, they are taught to despise each other, to destroy homes and lives, all in the name of liberty or religious beliefs. Waters highlights the danger of indoctrination and how it perpetuates the cycle of violence from one generation to the next.

Ultimately, the lyrics convey a sense of defiance and resistance against societal lies and propaganda. Waters asserts that while it is impossible to turn back time, individuals have the power to reject and challenge the dominant narratives imposed on them. By saying "Fuck you" to the powers that be and refusing to listen to their "bullshit and lies," individuals can reclaim their agency and strive for a more authentic and truthful existence.