The lyrics depict a scene where a child visits Montauk and sees their two fathers in various everyday situations, hoping that they will want to stay but knowing they have to leave eventually. The song also alludes to a woman from the past who waits in the ocean, symbolizing the passage of time and the inevitability of departure.

Meaning of "Montauk" by Rufus Wainwright

"Montauk" by Rufus Wainwright paints a poignant picture of family, time, and the transient nature of life. The child visiting Montauk represents the passing of generations and the cyclical nature of existence. The different images of the fathers portray different facets of their personalities, showing the complexity and depth of human relationships. The mention of a woman waiting in the ocean adds a mystical element to the song, symbolizing memories, nostalgia, and the inevitability of mortality. Ultimately, the lyrics convey a sense of both longing to stay and acceptance of the impermanence of life, capturing the bittersweet essence of family ties and the passing of time.