Meaning of "Islands" by Sara Bareilles

In "Islands," Sara Bareilles delves into the complexities of relationships and the struggle to find a balance between vulnerability and self-preservation. The song explores the concept of creating personal boundaries and becoming an island as a means of protecting oneself from emotional harm. The lyrics suggest that the speaker has experienced disappointment and heartbreak in the past, leading to a sense of caution and the need to establish distance in her current relationship. By using the metaphor of an island, Bareilles emphasizes the importance of self-reliance and maintaining a sense of individuality within the context of a partnership.

The repeated phrase "You must become an island" emphasizes the necessity of self-protection and reinforces the idea that relying solely on others for emotional well-being is futile. It suggests that the speaker has learned from past experiences and is now prioritizing self-care above all else. The imagery of "the water will only rise" signifies the inevitability of challenges and hardships in any relationship. The speaker acknowledges that while she cares deeply for her partner, she cannot neglect her own needs and well-being in the process.

Bareilles also discusses the fear of intimacy and the vulnerabilities that come with allowing someone to get close. The line "You always dirty up the windows" suggests that the speaker's partner avoids seeing the truth and hiding behind a facade to protect themselves from potential heartbreak. However, the speaker acknowledges that she, too, has made exceptions to her own rules when it comes to their relationship, indicating that both parties are grappling with their own vulnerabilities and fears.

Ultimately, "Islands" serves as a reminder that individuals must prioritize their own emotional well-being and establish boundaries within relationships. It highlights the need for self-sufficiency and self-awareness, urging listeners to find strength in their individuality and to understand that the only certainty in life is the ever-changing horizon.