Meaning of "Criminal" by Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox

The song explores the theme of guilt, remorse, and the desire for redemption. The narrator acknowledges her mistakes and takes responsibility for her actions. She refers to herself as a "bad bad girl," recognizing that she has been careless with someone she considers delicate. This suggests that she has caused harm or hurt someone, possibly emotionally, and regrets her actions. The line "I've come to you 'cause I need guidance to be true, and I just don't know where I can begin" portrays a sense of desperation as she seeks guidance and direction on how to make amends.

The narrator is aware of the consequences of her actions, referencing the "evil deeds" that she wants to be saved from before committing them. However, she also struggles with the fact that she continues to live in the present without considering the future consequences. She admits her wrongs but finds it difficult to deny her impulses, as she hopes for salvation and forgiveness. The line "I've got a lot to lose and I'm bettin' high" reflects the stakes she feels are involved in seeking redemption, suggesting that there may be a significant risk or personal sacrifice involved.

The conflicting emotions and the plea for help from higher powers, such as heaven or angels, showcase the narrator's desire to break free from her destructive patterns. The references to "the devil" wanting to know what an angel would say imply an internal struggle between good and evil, as well as the desire for guidance and clarity.

Ultimately, the lyrics speak to the universal human desire for redemption and the agonizing search for forgiveness after causing harm. It captures the internal struggle of someone who recognizes their flaws and seeks to make amends, highlighting the complexity of human nature and our capacity for both good and bad.