Meaning of "Buffalo Nickel" by Shovels & Rope

"Buffalo Nickel" by Shovels & Rope touches on themes of miscommunication, misunderstanding, and conflict in relationships. The narrator's encounter at the counter represents a larger issue of friction and frustration in a relationship where both parties are trying to navigate around each other's actions and feelings, leading to a disconnect. The symbolism of the buffalo nickel, a valuable but outdated coin, could indicate a situation where the past is brought into a present exchange, creating tension and misalignment. The refrain of "You and I workin' around each other" highlights the struggle of trying to coexist and collaborate with someone while dealing with unresolved issues and differences that continue to push them apart. The song captures the complicated dynamics of relationships where attempts at communication and resolution often fall short, leaving both parties stuck in a cycle of discord.