Meaning of "Why Should I Cry For You?" by Sting

The lyrics of "Why Should I Cry For You?" delve into themes of longing, uncertainty, and lost love. The speaker seems to be reflecting on their own existence, questioning the purpose and direction of their life. The repetition of the phrase "would north be true?" suggests a desire for clarity and a definitive path to follow. The lyrics also express a sense of emptiness and loneliness, as the speaker relates their experience to drifting in vast and empty seas. The mention of "dark angels" following them over a "godless sea" further emphasizes this feeling of desolation and despair.

The mention of seeing the face of the person they once loved adds another layer to the lyrics. The stars losing their place could signify that the presence or memory of this person disrupts the speaker's perception of the world. They question why they must continue to think of this person and what purpose it serves. The repetition of the line "Why should I cry for you?" suggests a struggle with letting go and moving on. The speaker seems to grapple with the idea that perhaps they shouldn't feel sadness or cry over this person who is no longer a part of their life. It is a plea for emotional clarity and an understanding of why they should hold onto these feelings.

The lyrics also touch upon the idea of love and its complexities. The line "What would it mean to say 'I loved you in my fashion'?" suggests that the speaker may have loved this person in their own unique way, which might not align with traditional notions of love. This adds a layer of ambiguity to the nature of their relationship and the emotions tied to it.

Overall, "Why Should I Cry For You?" explores the internal struggle of longing for someone who is no longer present in one's life and questions the purpose and validity of holding onto these emotions.