The lyrics of "That Girl" by Tegan And Sara express a feeling of frustration and exhaustion with tough situations and fights, questioning when the narrator became someone they don't recognize. They express a desire to be true to themselves and not be someone's enemy, longing to go back to being the person they used to be.

Meaning of "That Girl" by Tegan And Sara

"That Girl" delves into introspection and the struggle to maintain a sense of identity in the face of challenges and relationship dynamics. The repetition of feeling sick and tired of tough situations and fights reflects a sense of weariness and dissatisfaction with the current state of affairs. The questions "When did I become that girl?" suggests a loss of self, a feeling of being disconnected from who the narrator used to be. The desire not to be anyone's enemy speaks to a wish for peace and authenticity, wanting to reclaim the person they once were. The introspective tone of the song highlights the internal conflict of recognizing one's own transformation and yearning for a return to a familiar sense of self. Overall, "That Girl" navigates the themes of identity, self-acceptance, and personal growth in the face of adversity.