The lyrics talk about the struggle of being stuck with personal demons and the desire to break free from them. The singer questions the blurred lines between themselves and their demons, wondering if they can overcome their past and find redemption. They express a desire to be like Paul Newman, someone who walks a righteous path and does something meaningful.

Meaning of "Paul Newman Vs. The Demons" by The Avett Brothers

"Paul Newman Vs. The Demons" delves into the internal battle of grappling with personal demons and the longing for redemption and change. The repetition of living through the past again reflects a cycle of self-destruction and inner turmoil that the singer wants to break free from. The comparison to Paul Newman, a symbol of integrity and purpose, highlights the desire to emulate someone who is able to make a positive impact and do something worthwhile. The lyrics convey a sense of self-awareness, acknowledging the destructive patterns but also showing a glimmer of hope and determination to overcome them. It's a reflection on the constant struggle between one's darker impulses and the aspiration to do good, to make a difference in the world.