The lyrics of "Polly Vaughn" tell the tragic tale of a hunter who accidentally kills his beloved Polly, mistaking her for a swan. As he grieves her death, Polly's ghost appears to him, reassuring him that he won't be convicted for the killing. In the end, during the trial, Polly's presence brings clarity to the situation.

Meaning of "Polly Vaughn" by The Dillards

"Polly Vaughn" recounts a story of mistaken identity, tragedy, guilt, and redemption. The hunter's fatal mistake, fueled by darkness and confusion, illustrates the consequences of acting without fully understanding the situation. Despite his deep remorse, Polly's ghost offers him a sense of relief and absolution, implying that innocence can be found even in the midst of tragedy. The presence of Polly's spirit during the trial signifies the importance of truth and clarity in seeking justice. The song delves into themes of remorse, forgiveness, and the transcendent power of love and loyalty that can extend even beyond death.