The narrator describes a peaceful scene with rainbows and dew drops, but is constantly receiving negative messages from someone. Despite the sender's efforts to upset them, the narrator insists they feel alright and questions why the sender is being mean.

Meaning of "Cold Milk Bottle" by The Mountain Goats

The lyrics of "Cold Milk Bottle" capture the internal struggle of staying resilient in the face of negativity and hostility from someone close to the narrator. The serene imagery of rainbows and dew drops juxtaposed with the hurtful messages from the sender highlights the contrast between outer tranquility and inner turmoil. Despite the repeated attempts to bring the narrator down, they defiantly claim to feel alright, emphasizing their resilience and ability to withstand the negativity. The repeated questioning of why the sender is being mean suggests a sense of hurt and confusion over the mistreatment, as well as a desire for the sender to recognize the impact of their actions. Overall, the lyrics explore themes of resilience, emotional manipulation, and the complexities of relationships.