Meaning of "Miscarriage" by The Plot In You

The lyrics of "Miscarriage" by The Plot In You explore the emotional journey of a narrator who experiences the loss of a baby through miscarriage. The narrator's initial connection with the baby is portrayed as something beautiful and hopeful, with the ability to feel and hear the life within the mother. The repetition of the pleas for the baby to keep breathing and the prayers for its happiness illustrate the desperation and love the narrator feels towards the unborn child.

However, the second half of the song reveals a darker and more resentful tone. The lyrics suggest that the narrator blames someone, possibly the father, for the loss of the baby. The mention of "I've done my best to respect you" implies a strained relationship with the person being addressed. The lyrics express a sense of betrayal and sadness, highlighting the narrator's regret and anger towards this person.

The repetition of the line "Why can't I be dreaming?" indicates a desire to escape from the painful reality of the loss. It represents the narrator's longing for an alternate reality where the miscarriage didn't happen, and the pain they are feeling is just a nightmare. This longing for escape reflects the deep emotional impact of the loss and the struggle to come to terms with it.

In summary, "Miscarriage" explores the complex emotions surrounding the loss of a baby through miscarriage. It delves into themes of love, heartbreak, blame, and the desperate desire for an alternate reality.