Meaning of "September" by The Shins

The lyrics of "September" delve into the theme of love and its ability to overcome personal shortcomings and external obstacles. The reference to Pontus giving up a pearl represents the sacrifices and gifts exchanged within a relationship. The imagery of being a thousand miles away from each other suggests physical separation, yet the court of angels and the future forming imply a spiritual connection and a sense of hope. The protagonist acknowledges their flaws but also reveals a better side to their personality, which their partner cherishes. The metaphor of love as "the ink in the well when her body writes" highlights the transformative power of love and its influence on one's actions and expressions. The song also touches on the vulnerability of the protagonist, who is overwhelmed by the beauty and fragility of their surroundings. The darkness that will eventually touch their lives acknowledges the inevitable challenges they will face, but the mention of the partner as an extraordinary valentine suggests that their love provides a guiding light even in difficult times.

The message conveyed in "September" is one of acceptance and unconditional love. It acknowledges human flaws and the inevitable struggles that come with relationships, but it emphasizes the importance of recognizing and appreciating the goodness in one another. The protagonist's vulnerability and self-awareness demonstrate growth and a willingness to change, while the partner's ability to love in spite of imperfections reflects their deep connection and understanding.