Meaning of "What Difference Does It Make?" by The Smiths

"What Difference Does It Make?" delves into the complex emotions and dynamics of a relationship. The opening line, "All men have secrets and here is mine," sets the tone for the song, suggesting that everyone has hidden parts of themselves. The speaker's vulnerability is apparent as they confess their secret, seemingly revealing their true self to the person they address. This act of disclosure indicates a deep level of trust and reliance on the individual, as evident in the line "I think I can rely on you."

However, the mood quickly shifts as the person begins to distance themselves from the narrator, as seen in the line "And yet you start to recoil." This shift introduces a sense of rejection and creates a contrast between the initial trust and the subsequent emotional distance. The use of the phrase "heavy words are so lightly thrown" suggests that the person may not fully understand or appreciate the weight of the narrator's feelings, causing further emotional turmoil for the speaker.

The theme of dependence and obedience emerges when the speaker confesses to stealing and lying, explaining that they did so because they were asked to. This illustrates how the narrator is willing to compromise their own morality in order to please the person they address. The line "Because you asked me to" highlights the influence and control the individual has over the narrator.

The chorus, with the repeated question "So, what difference does it make?" reflects a sense of resignation and questioning the significance of their actions. It suggests that despite all their efforts and sacrifices, the outcome remains unchanged. The phrase "Oh, it makes none, but now you have gone" further emphasizes the notion of futility and the realization that their actions ultimately bear no meaning or difference in the end.

There is an undercurrent of shame and regret throughout the song. The speaker feels ashamed of their actions, as indicated in the line "But now you make me feel so ashamed." This remorse stems from their realization that they have compromised their integrity for the person they address. The line "You won't see me anymore" hints at the consequences of their actions, suggesting that the person has walked away due to their recognition of the speaker's true nature.

Overall, "What Difference Does It Make?" delves into themes of secrecy, dependence, shame, and the futile nature of certain sacrifices in a relationship. It explores the complexities of human emotions and the consequences of compromising one's own values for another.