Meaning of "Crowing" by Toad The Wet Sprocket

The lyrics of "Crowing" delve into the complexities of unrequited love and the struggle to maintain a relationship. The opening lines set the stage by suggesting that the person being addressed could have been happier if their partner had made up their mind. This implies that there was a lack of commitment, leading the protagonist to offer themselves to others who were willing to cross the line of uncertainty. It becomes clear that the protagonist feels unfulfilled and longing for a deeper connection.

The repetition of the lines "And it was never a question" emphasizes the certainty of the situation – that the partner's hesitation and lack of commitment were never in question. The word "crowing" is used metaphorically to describe the partner's need for attention and validation, suggesting that they thrived on the protagonist's love and affection, yet were unable to fully commit.

As the lyrics progress, the protagonist reflects on their actions and the regrets they feel. While they were asleep, oblivious to the partner's true nature, the partner was already hiding their flaws and secrets. The reference to shedding skin indicates that the protagonist has exposed their vulnerabilities to the partner, yet the partner remains uninterested in a lasting relationship. The air lingering in the throat symbolizes the unspoken words and emotions that continue to weigh heavily on the protagonist even when they try to call the partner their friend.

The second verse introduces a cold and distant atmosphere, with the protagonist staring at a "cold little hand" and reading fault lines in the partner's character. The imagery suggests that the partner is emotionally detached and has revealed their true self – a mere shell of a person. The protagonist, hoping for guidance or some divine intervention, receives no answer, emphasizing the lack of resolution or closure they seek.

In the final repetition of the chorus, the protagonist acknowledges that they were also "crowing for repair," showing their own participation in the relationship's breakdown. Despite offering love and affection, the protagonist couldn't make the partner stay. This could highlight the idea that relationships are a two-way street, and both parties need to be willing to commit for it to work.

Overall, the lyrics of "Crowing" explore the pain and frustration of unrequited love and the inability to maintain a fulfilling relationship. It conveys a sense of longing for something deeper and a recognition that love and affection alone cannot fix a broken commitment.