Meaning of "A Boy Brushed Red... Living in Black and White" by Underoath

The lyrics of "A Boy Brushed Red... Living in Black and White" delve into the complexities of a troubled relationship filled with regret, fear, addiction, and the consequences of one's actions. The opening lines paint a vivid picture of tension and anxiety, with references to a racing heartbeat and the taste of fear in someone's sweat. It suggests that something has gone terribly wrong in the relationship and that regret has settled in.

The chorus reflects the internal conflict within the protagonist. They admit their foolishness for the other person, despite the awareness that things have gone too far and regret fills their interactions. The lines "Here is where we both go wrong" hint at a recurring pattern of mistakes in the relationship, emphasizing the destructive nature of their connection.

As the song progresses, it intensifies with a sense of urgency and desperation. The protagonist acknowledges that they are both living in denial, ignoring the truth of their situation. They refer to the present moment as their last chance to do what they want, as if they are on the brink of losing everything. The line "My heart is dead and it's way past beating" metaphorically represents the emotional toll taken on both individuals, with their lungs failing and their hearts no longer beating.

The song also touches on the theme of addiction, as the protagonist confesses to being addicted to the other person. This addiction and the fear of being alone drive their choices and actions, further perpetuating their destructive cycle.

The lyrics take a dark turn towards the end, with references to self-harm and the realization that the protagonist never thought they would make it out alive. The line "It doesn't matter what you say, you never mattered anyway" suggests a sense of bitterness and resentment towards the other person, indicating that their relationship has become toxic and hurtful.

In essence, "A Boy Brushed Red... Living in Black and White" serves as a haunting portrayal of a dysfunctional relationship filled with regret, fear, addiction, and the consequences of one's actions. It explores the devastating effects of denial and the deep-rooted emotions that can lead to self-destruction.