The lyrics depict a conversation or inner dialogue with someone named Polly, who seems to be in distress and asking for help. The speaker acknowledges Polly's wishes for basic needs like water and food, but there is also a darker undertone where Polly asks to be untied and the speaker mentions cutting herself.

Meaning of "Polly" by Walk Off The Earth

These lyrics present a complex and potentially disturbing narrative. The repeated phrases indicate a sense of entrapment or manipulation, as Polly is repeatedly asked to "cut yourself" and "please myself". The speaker seems to be in a position of power, offering Polly help but with self-serving intentions. There is a disturbing juxtaposition between Polly's basic needs and her requests for self-harm, hinting at a cycle of abuse or harmful behavior. The song could be interpreted as a metaphor for toxic relationships where one person exerts control over another, disguising manipulation as assistance. The tone of the song is eerie and unsettling, reflecting a sense of unease and discomfort.