Meaning of "You're the Wish You Are I Had" by XTC

The song "You're the Wish You Are I Had" by XTC delves into the idea of yearning for an idealized version of someone. The narrator describes how they created this perfect woman in their mind, only to later encounter her in reality. This encounter blurs the lines between fantasy and reality, as the woman represents all the unfulfilled desires and wishes the narrator has carried within them. The repetition of the phrase "You're the wish you are I had" reinforces the idea of longing and the internal conflict of reconciling what is wished for with what is truly obtainable. The lyrics also touch on the consequences of unfulfilled wishes, suggesting that wishing may be seen as a negative act but also acknowledging the transformative power of desire. Overall, the song explores the complexities of desire, fantasy, and reality, offering a poignant reflection on the nature of longing and the search for fulfillment.